A Year of Rachel Held Evans Womanhood

Justin Taylor does what he can to puncture the bubble surrounding Rachel Held Evans’ book A Year of Biblical Womanhood:

Evangelicals, like Trillia Newbell, have been less than impressed. “In this book Evans is trying to build a bridge, but I wonder if it is not rather a comfortable bridge for shaky evangelicals to find their way into theological liberalism.” Even one secular-postmodern-feminist writer saw through the gimmicky nature of the project and judged that the whole thing ended up making a “mockery” of the Bible.

He includes a link to a lengthy review of the book by Kathy Keller, in which I think she takes the book more seriously than Evans took her subject.

One thought on “A Year of Rachel Held Evans Womanhood

  1. Jason, Kathy Keller may be taking Rachel’s book more seriously than Rachel took her subject but I think that’s because she is aware that many readers will take Rachel’s book more seriously than that.

    Unfortunately all too many readers take books more seriously than even their authors; responsible authors are aware of that and write accordingly, and I would expect this especially from Christian authors.

    I cannot count how many times I have heard a view of prayer expressed which makes God’s power contingent on our incessant praying, and which is based on Frank Peretti’s novels; or more recently heard a spirituality espoused that minimizes sin and negates the church, on the basis of “The Shack.”

    The same is likely to happen with Rachel’s book: readers will cite it as evidence that the Bible is a misogynistic book, and Rachel as the author cannot completely escape responsibility for that – which is Kathy’s point.

Leave a Reply